The right to protest where it matters
As of this writing, reports on social media and from local news outlets describe an ongoing protest march by youth groups and other sectors in Cebu. From what I have gathered, the protesters are assembling at the SSS junction along P. del Rosario Street and at Fuente Osmeña before converging on Colon Street, in front of a major department store.
The protests coincide with the 49th ASEAN Summit and Related Summits, which opened last Sunday, November 15, at the Philippine International Convention Center (PICC) in Pasay City. The Plus One Summits, which bring ASEAN leaders together with dialogue partners including the U.S., China, Japan, Australia, India, and others, are scheduled for November 16 and 17.
The summit opening on Sunday was marked by confrontations between police and protesters at Liwasang Bonifacio in Manila, an hour’s walk away from the primary summit venue at the PICC in Pasay City. According to reports, demonstrators opposing the US-led Pax Silica initiative and the visit of U.S. President Donald Trump attempted to march toward the PICC, where ASEAN leaders were gathering. Protesters later retreated to Liwasang Bonifacio, a designated freedom park. Nevertheless, police arrested several demonstrators within the park itself. Rappler reported at least 11 arrests.
In a separate incident in Sucat, Muntinlupa City, more than 200 protesters were arrested. Amnesty International Philippines, citing reports of approximately 300 protesters detained across the demonstrations, called for their immediate release and condemned the police response. The National Capital Region Police Office said that demonstrators had refused to disperse, conducted protests without permits, obstructed traffic, and defied lawful authorities.
This is an occasion to discuss the right to peaceful assembly in view of the government's apparent allergy to protest actions whenever summits and other international events are held in the country. Some people question the timing of the protests: Are we not supposed to put our most hospitable foot forward when welcoming foreign visitors?
On the other hand, protesters rightly argue that demonstrating against a government policy carries greater weight when world leaders are gathered nearby to negotiate that very policy. Location and timing give a protest urgency and meaning. More so, the presence of its intended audience gives it relevance.
While the government has a legitimate responsibility to protect visiting heads of state and other foreign dignitaries, their presence does not automatically extinguish the public's right to protest within reasonable proximity to the summit venue. Nor does it negate the concomitant duty of law enforcement authorities to observe maximum tolerance. The appropriate response is proportionate security management, not indiscriminate suppression.
In Bayan v. Ermita (2006), the Supreme Court reaffirmed the doctrine of maximum tolerance in the regulation of public assemblies. Authorities may impose reasonable restrictions to maintain public order and security, but these must be justified by legitimate considerations, not by a generalized fear of disruption or, in the present case, a desire to spare the government embarrassment before its international guests. Nor does every inconvenience to motorists, interruption of normal activities, or refusal to comply with a police directive automatically justify mass arrests or the forcible dispersal of an assembly.
The legality of police intervention must be assessed in light of the circumstances, including the lawfulness of the restrictions or directives being enforced. In the context of the ASEAN Summit, the government's duty is not simply to protect the summit from protesters, but to protect both the summit and the protesters' constitutional rights.
A government that invokes public safety to suppress peaceful dissent, when reasonable measures could accommodate both security and the right to protest, risks turning legitimate regulation into the very kind of preemptive repression that the Supreme Court rejected in Bayan v. Ermita.
- Latest















