^

Opinion

Scraping the bottom of the barrel

THE POLITICAL HECKLER - Ronald Llamas - The Philippine Star

Vice President Sara Duterte’s defense team has run out of excuses, if it ever had any, for failing to refute the House prosecution’s case over more than P800 million in allegedly undeclared wealth.

With testimonies from the Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC), the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR), bank officials, a financial forensic expert and legal experts, among others, the prosecution has built a case that Sara’s lawyers are finding exceedingly difficult to repudiate. With several other impeachment charges already dropped, this remaining charge alone appears to be giving the defense more than enough trouble. They are practically scraping the bottom of the barrel for credible answers.

After a mass exodus of witnesses, including bank officials and a constitutional law expert who reportedly had second thoughts about testifying, the Vice President’s lawyers have been left with witnesses who either suffer from selective amnesia or have managed to dig their client into an even deeper hole.

First came the Davao City assessor, who, when asked about his all-expenses-paid trip to China, could not even remember when he went. Next was a Davao City accountant, who could not recall important documents, not even those she had signed. Then there was the Island Garden City of Samal assessor, who could not remember the records, locations or acquisition dates of properties owned by the Dutertes.

And who could forget the GenCorp corporate lawyer, who claimed that Sara was not a stockholder of the company allegedly linked to more than P200 million, which formed part of her total undeclared wealth? This is the same GenCorp that Sara repeatedly declared in her SALNs as having business interests, alongside other companies. The logic is simple enough. If Sara is not a GenCorp stockholder, then there is nothing to explain.

Except that the witness herself admitted that Sara received P2.14 million from GenCorp over several years, supposedly as a “return of capital” from her “loose investment.” And Sara received this money while serving as vice president. Talk about digging your way out of one mess only to bury yourself in another.

For one, the Constitution prohibits the vice president, and even the president, from directly or indirectly participating in any business while in office. For another, Sara never declared these supposed returns of capital in her SALNs over the years. Even if we assume, without conceding, that this explanation holds water, her defense has just admitted that she failed to disclose financial information in her SALNs. That hardly makes the problem disappear. It simply provides another basis for betrayal of public trust, itself an impeachable offense.

But there is rhyme and reason for this madness. In trying to extricate Sara from the GenCorp mess, her lawyers appear willing to concede a supposedly “smaller” transgression to make the gargantuan one disappear. This became obvious when Sal Panelo, the brilliant lawyer who apparently didn’t make the cut for Sara’s defense team, dismissed her repeated declarations of GenCorp in her SALNs as nothing more than an “honest mistake.”

What a joke. How does one repeatedly declare a corporation as a business interest in their SALNs, only to claim that no such interest exists? Forgetting an asset you own is plausible. But repeatedly declaring an interest in a company you supposedly have none in?

Is Sara’s camp seriously asking the public to believe that the Vice President is so delusional, clueless or even stupid that she doesn’t know what she repeatedly declares in her own SALNs?

Panelo insists that even if a mistake is made numerous times, it is still permissible as long as it is “honest.” By that logic, perhaps his atrocious fashion choices are not deliberate either, just a series of honest mistakes that somehow keep happening.

But if you think Sara’s defense team has already hit rock bottom, think again. Perhaps compensating for its weak witnesses, Sara’s lawyers resorted to playing video clips of prominent dead people whose words, replayed from an old impeachment trial, could no longer be cross-examined in the present proceedings. Not only were the clips irrelevant and little more than an appeal to emotion, but they were also a fitting metaphor for Sara’s defense: dead.

To top it all, Sara’s lawyers presented Atty. Rainer dela Fuente, a former Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) financial investigator who reportedly served for only 25 months, yet was paraded as an expert on anti-money laundering and financial investigation. Senator-judge Raffy Tulfo dubbed him a “super witness” for having an answer for everything, even on matters involving the Supreme Court, the ombudsman, the DOJ and the amici curiae.

During Akbayan Rep. Chel Diokno’s brilliant cross-examination, the “all-knowing” witness, who kept on blabbering about the prosecution’s forensic financial report, its methodology and findings, confessed that he had not been given a copy of the report before testifying. Pressed further, he also admitted that he had no evidence that the prosecution’s records were false or fabricated. In fact, he categorically disclaimed any claim that the AMLC, bank, BIR or SEC records used against Sara were inaccurate, untruthful, tampered with or fabricated. Not a few watching the trial must have shouted in unison: “Then what the hell are you doing there in the first place?”

Clearly, Sara’s defense team has nothing to offer the trial. It has no credible witnesses and no coherent answers to the allegations against the Vice President. It promised to dismantle the charges against Sara. Instead, it has repeatedly done the prosecution’s job.

For those still asking whether Sara is guilty, look at the overwhelming evidence, and then look at the defense itself. Of course, a weak defense does not, by itself, establish guilt. But the defense’s sheer inadequacy makes the prosecution’s case harder to dismiss and only strengthens the case for Sara’s culpability.

SARA DUTERTE

  • Latest
  • Trending
Latest
Latest
abtest
Are you sure you want to log out?
X
Login

Philstar.com is one of the most vibrant, opinionated, discerning communities of readers on cyberspace. With your meaningful insights, help shape the stories that can shape the country. Sign up now!

Get Updated:

Signup for the News Round now

FORGOT PASSWORD?
SIGN IN
or sign in with