^

Opinion

A new government must start from scratch

BREAKTHROUGH - Elfren S. Cruz - The Philippine Star

Over the past decade, there has been a growing sentiment around the world, including the Philippines, that democracies are facing a crisis of credibility. According to a PEW survey in 2025, nearly 60 percent of respondents in 23 countries agreed that they are “dissatisfied with democracy.” Polarization, disinformation and disillusionment with leaders who are willing to break established norms for personal advantage are to blame for this growing sense of dysfunction.

There is, however, a deeper flaw in today’s democratic governments. State agencies and institutions are increasingly unable to perform the basic tasks they were designed to carry out.

For example, the Departments of Public Works and Education are among the agencies that, year after year, have simply been unable to get rid of corruption. This has caused crisis in flood control projects and in the building of adequate number of school buildings.

Another set of examples is corruption in the Bureau of Internal Revenue and in the Bureau of Customs, that corruption is allegedly so embedded in their systems.

Twenty-five years ago, liberal democracy seemed to be the accepted future for world governments. Now, democracies are struggling to survive. Even in western countries, populist far-right governments are winning more support from the people.

In the Philippines, under the presidency of Noynoy Aquino, this country was seen as a rising “economic tiger of Asia.” There were also major gains in the war against corruption. However, the succeeding administration, the Duterte regime, reversed all of this and the Philippines became an economic laggard again. Corruption became widespread once more and a so-called war against drugs resulted in thousands of innocent lives being killed without following the rule of law.

Despite the breakdown of the rule of law during the Duterte regime, there are now increasing calls for a return to “strong arm rule” to replace democracy. This call is now being heard in the so-called educated class and the business sector.

At a recent luncheon of business people that I attended, the majority of the guests were actually proposing that only a bloody revolution can solve corruption in this country.

Globally, the 2008 financial crisis fueled the collapse of voter confidence in the existing mainstream parties and institutions. At that time, center left parties failed to offer programs that would benefit the lower class and reduce income inequality. This failure led to the rise of populist parties and movements. At no time in the world’s history has the gap between the rich and the poor been as wide as it is now.

In the minds of many of the common people, democracy simply leads to the rich getter richer, and the poor getting poorer. It is a fact that the present democratic regimes are still believers in the concept of the “trickle down” policy as a means of allowing the majority of the population to share in a country’s economic growth. This has not happened. Even the late Pope Francis in some of his encyclicals wrote that the “trickle down” policy has failed and will not work.

To end the total breakdown of democratic institutions, intellectuals and political leaders will need to reimagine and reinvent the concept of a liberal democracy. There must be a new framework for a social contract that will provide more people across society with economic security and opportunity. The old alternative was communism; but this ideology has proven to be a failure. However, there is a new ideology that is gaining strength in the western world. This is social democracy and democratic socialism.

This ideological movement is led by Sen. Bernie Sanders and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez in the United States. It calls for a regulated market economy, an aggressive welfare program like universal health care and a living wage. It also calls for taxing the very rich and even imposing a wealth tax. This is a tax based on the assets of an individual.

The incoming administration must be ready to start from scratch and not just replicate what they are trying to replace.

There are those in the social democratic movement who believe that institutional reforms are not adequate. In his book “Inside Bureaucracy,” the economist Anthony Downs described how institutions that lose their ability to adapt must now be either reborn or totally destroyed. Democracies around the world need to give serious attention to institutional rebirth. This means rebuilding state agencies, especially agencies which are beyond even reinvention and should be shut down all together.

For example, the Department of Public Works may be shut down and replaced by an entirely new agency. This includes other agencies like PhilHealth and the Bureau of Customs. If the Philippines wants to solve the current crisis in our country, we will have to seriously consider creating new institutions and totally closing existing institutions in order to restore faith in democracy again. Governments must deliver what they promise.

*      *      *

Email: [email protected]

CREDIBILITY

  • Latest
  • Trending
Latest
Latest
abtest
Recommended
Are you sure you want to log out?
X
Login

Philstar.com is one of the most vibrant, opinionated, discerning communities of readers on cyberspace. With your meaningful insights, help shape the stories that can shape the country. Sign up now!

Get Updated:

Signup for the News Round now

FORGOT PASSWORD?
SIGN IN
or sign in with