^

Opinion

The Phl arbitral victory and the need to keep enforcing it

POINT OF VIEW - Jemy Gatdula - The Philippine Star

This year marks the 10th anniversary of the Philippines’ overwhelming victory in its South China Sea arbitral case against China. Incredibly, a decade on, disinformation and outright lies are still being spread, in a vain attempt to diminish the Arbitral Award’s significance. One such claim is that the Award did not, in fact, strengthen Philippine sovereignty (i.e., ownership) over the disputed islands. But that is essentially a fallacy, a strawman, if there ever was one.

Admittedly, the Award must be understood correctly: it did not determine territorial sovereignty over the Spratlys or Panatag (Scarborough) Shoal nor did it invalidate China’s claims of ownership over particular land features. But what the Award did was to declare China’s expansive maritime claims, particularly those based on “historic rights” within the “nine-dash line,” to be a pathetic lie.

The Award, equally importantly, defined with specificity territorial features, such as islands, rocks and low-tide elevations. It thus expounded and clarified the Nov. 19, 2012 ruling of the International Court of Justice in the Territorial and Maritime Dispute (Nicaragua v. Colombia) case.

Much has been made about the difference between sovereignty and sovereign rights but that is easily resolved by understanding the relationship between territorial sovereignty and maritime entitlements.

This is significant because the Arbitral Tribunal was never asked to determine territorial sovereignty but instead to determine the parties’ maritime entitlements under UNCLOS and whether China’s conduct violated that Convention. Such point addressed any jurisdictional concern while establishing the fact that a State need not establish ownership over a particular island to enjoy maritime entitlements generated by its mainland or archipelagic baselines. Obversely, a claim to a supposed “island” does not automatically entitle a State to an EEZ or continental shelf if the feature does not satisfy Article 121 of UNCLOS.

Gratifyingly, the Award reinforces the constitutional foundations of Philippine maritime policy. Article II.7 of the Constitution requires an independent foreign policy that gives paramount consideration to national sovereignty, territorial integrity and national interest. Article XII.2 places natural resources under the full control and supervision of the State and expressly requires the protection of national marine wealth in the exclusive economic zone.

These constitutional obligations are supported by longstanding legislation. Presidential Decree 1599 (1978) established the Philippine EEZ and recognized sovereign rights over its natural resources. Presidential Decree 1596 (1978) declared the Kalayaan Island Group part of Philippine territory. These are distinct legal bases: the former concerns maritime entitlements, while the latter asserts territorial sovereignty. The Award did not decide the latter question but it strengthened the former.

In turn, Republic Act 12064 (the Philippine Maritime Zones Act of 2024) further clarifies this framework by expressly incorporating the Arbitral Award into the statutory framework governing the exercise of Philippine maritime rights and jurisdiction, while updating the country’s maritime zones legislation.

A particularly eccentric and defeatist argument hurled against the Award is that it is supposedly futile considering China’s allegedly vast military “superiority.” But the disparity in military strength between China and the Philippines does not diminish the legal significance or correctness of the Award.

International law does not condition the validity of a State’s maritime rights on the size of its navy, its economic resources or ability to occupy disputed features. If military strength were the measure of legal entitlement, international law would have no meaning for smaller states. The entire purpose of a rules-based international order is to establish legal standards that apply independently of the relative power of the states concerned.

So, even admitting the assumption that China possesses substantially greater military and economic resources (SIPRI estimated China’s military expenditure at approximately $336 billion in 2025, compared with approximately $6.4 billion for the Philippines), such may have real and indeed practical consequences for the Philippines’ ability to enforce its maritime rights but – to reiterate – China’s military superiority is not a source of maritime entitlement under UNCLOS.

In fact, the foregoing simply supports Defense Secretary Gilberto Teodoro’s consistent push for four percent of GDP increase in defense spending. Constitutionally, such position is sound (see Guingona v Carague, 1991), while economically a sustained defense investment contributes to economic growth by expanding advanced manufacturing, logistics, research and development, infrastructure and skilled employment (see National Security and the Philippine Defense Economy, 2024, CentralBooks).

The Philippines presently spends only about 1.3 to 1.5 percent of GDP on defense. Singapore’s defense spending is maintained at approximately three percent of its GDP. Taiwan’s spending is 3.32 percent. NATO treats two percent as its minimum. South Korea spends roughly 2.8 percent, while Poland now exceeds four percent in response to a deteriorating security environment. An archipelagic state confronting sustained coercion in the West Philippine Sea has no strategic justification for prolonged underinvestment.

Ultimately, the Arbitral Award cannot enforce itself. The Philippines must consequently develop the maritime capabilities, diplomatic relationships and institutional capacity necessary to protect its rights. Legal entitlement and effective enforcement are separate matters, and both require steely resolve and sustained national attention.

*   *   *

Jemy Gatdula is the Dean of the UA&P Law School and is a Philippine Judicial Academy lecturer for constitutional philosophy and jurisprudence.

CHINA

  • Latest
  • Trending
Latest
Latest
abtest
Recommended
Are you sure you want to log out?
X
Login

Philstar.com is one of the most vibrant, opinionated, discerning communities of readers on cyberspace. With your meaningful insights, help shape the stories that can shape the country. Sign up now!

Get Updated:

Signup for the News Round now

FORGOT PASSWORD?
SIGN IN
or sign in with