Impeaching the "expert witnesses" for the defense
The universal definition of an "expert witness" is that it is a person with specialized knowledge or recognized expertise who provides testimony to help the court understand complex issues in a pending legal case. Testimonies from an expert witness have the strong tendency to influence the final decision of the judge.
Applying this definition to the ongoing impeachment trial, we submit that the so-called expert witnesses presented by the defense miserably failed to achieve its objective. Both the prosecution and the defense have the distinct right to select expert witnesses focusing on the qualifications, communication skills, and demeanor as well as reputation and standing in society. Expert witnesses are expected to guide the trial court to understand the complicated issues presented before the judges and to discern the truth based on competent analysis of too much information, data, figures, and statistics.
Not any Tom, Dick, or Harry can be called to serve as expert witness. The side that presents such a witness should lay the predicate and qualifying the witness by showing convincing evidence of expertise. Expert witness testimony is grounded in specialized knowledge connected to the general principles of the trial or deposition. This testimony helps ensure a fair trial by providing important contextual data, facts and information regarding the case or incident. This demonstrates how important expert witnesses are in ensuring a fair trial.
Under our Revised Rules of Court, which have supplementary effect on the impeachment trial, only the court has the power to determine whether or not a witness really qualifies as an expert. Such determination is fundamental because without such affirmation of expertise, the testimony given by such witness would have zero probative value.
The Rules of Court do provide that only the court, in this case, the Senate Impeachment Court, can determine whether a witness has been sufficiently shown to possess the requisite credentials, well-recognized expertise, and reputed credibility and stature relative to a specific issue being litigated. In this connection, an entry-level junior investigator like Rainer de la Fuente can qualify as an expert. However, this witness was not able to answer questions which he should have been able to readily explain if he were really an expert.
Congressman Chel Diokno, a veteran legal luminary and experienced trial lawyer, son of the famous senator and former Department of Justice secretary Jose W. Diokno, was able to impeach the so-called "expert witness" by showing his limited experience, his short stint as investigator, and his departure from AMLC after not having been promoted from his entry-level position. Prosecutor Diokno suceeded in demolishing his touted expertise.
With due respect, De la Fuente was not able to prove his own expertise. The content of his answers and the manner of his testimony as well as his overall demeanor before the impeachment court have all demonstrated that he was not able to convince most of the senator-judges that he really knew what he was asked to testify about. He did not even read the documents he was supposed to refute. His testimony, instead of helping the defense, has given aid and comfort to the prosecution.
With due respect, De la Fuente's testimony left many questions unanswered. In fact, it raised more questions instead of answering the queries propounded by the prosecution as well as the matters raised by concerned senator-judges. I think that the defense is imploding and there is no need for the prosecution to make any rebuttal. I may be wrong, of course, or they may accuse me of bias or prejudice, but I think it is time to rest the case. And let the court render its verdict before Santa Claus comes to town for Christmas.
There is no expert who can destroy the truth, and the truth has been sufficiently shown by convincing evidence. There is enough evidence that can convince an unbiased mind to make a logical conclusion. We should all rest this case and starting wrapping up for Christmas. Santa, like Rudolph, already knows who has been naughty and who has been nice. Let the gavel fall no matter who gets hurt. Justice is for all experts or no experts at all.
- Latest















