More harm than good
The Philippines’ stint in hosting the summit and related meetings of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations is over. For those who worked on the sidelines or behind the events, kudos to you. You can now finally rest. I can say the same to fellow journalists who extended their hours to cover milestone moments during the event. Now that Singapore is preparing to fill the shoes of the Philippines, I look back at the past few days and wonder whether the summit brought more harm than good.
In Cebu, for instance, protesters composed of students, labor groups and vendors marched down the streets to express their opposition to the Pax Silica initiative and the arrival of U.S. President Donald Trump for the ASEAN meetings. What followed was a mess. Several videos surfaced online showing how a seemingly-contained effigy burning became the center of attention, causing panic among authorities and prompting the use of a fire extinguisher. This later escalated into pushing and pulling between protesters and state forces. Days after, we saw footage of a man in black holding a firearm in that scene.
Over in Manila, more than 200 protesters were detained because they wanted to air their grievances. We later found out that campus journalists were among those detained. Whether they were there to join the protest or cover it is a discussion in itself. The point is that they were forcibly pulled out of their assembly, seemingly without clear basis. Although they were eventually released and the incident was extensively covered, the damage had already been done.
It will be difficult for the parties involved to mend their strained relationship, if there was one to begin with. The local government has expressed regret over the incidents. Cebu City officials have also called for dialogue. At this point, however, those who simply wanted to use their voices for their causes are left analyzing what went wrong and why constitutional provisions seem not to be working at all.
We are proud of how our democracy works, especially when compared with some of our ASEAN neighbors. But in reality, the text does not speak for itself. Rights written into the Constitution mean little if people cannot exercise them without fear of being pushed, detained, or silenced. We remain at the mercy of those in power, and the events surrounding the summit have offered another reminder of that uncomfortable truth. To top it all off, President Trump’s stay in the Philippines seemed to have been celebrated by his supporters. His casual exchanges with our own president may have aggravated those who feel strongly about his administration’s actions and the war in the Middle East.
The summit may have been a diplomatic success on paper but if its staging came at the expense of people’s rights and the public’s ability to speak freely, then we should ask what exactly we are celebrating. Hosting an international event is an achievement, yes, but protecting the people who make their voices heard should be one, too.
- Latest















