Juan Co, the Chinese who was refused entry by the Americans in the Port of Cebu
On January 17, 1905, a Chinese by the name of Juan Ocaba aboard a ship was refused admission in the shores of Cebu. The order came from James J. Rafferty, the Collector of Customs in Cebu. Juan Ocaba, appealed the order of the American Collector, the decision however was affirmed by the Insular Government. Juan, however was given the chance to remain on shore pending his appeal provided he pay the bond of $1,000 (one thousand American dollars).
Juan Co claimed that he was the son of a Filipino woman and a Chinese merchant, that he was born in Cebu, but when he was 6 years old, his father brought him to China, and at 17 years old came back to the Philippines. He returned alone, his father decided to stay in China.
On February 23, 1905, the Court of First Instance of Cebu granted the petition of Co Quip Jat to adopt Juan Ocaba now known as Juan Co. On the other hand, the appeal of Juan Co of the decision of the American Collector of Customs of denying him entry to Cebu was affirmed by the Secretary of Finance and Justice (at that time, the department of justice and finance belongs to one department and headed by one secretary).
Days following the granting of the judicial adoption of Juan Co (formerly Juan Ocaba), the latter filed a petition before the Court of First Instance for an injunction to prohibit the Collector of Customs to deport Juan.
On April 14, 1906, the Court of First Instance declared that the Collector of Customs was in default since it did not submit an answer to the petition of Juan Co against the Collector.
James J. Rafferty, the Collector of Customs of Cebu questioned the decision of the Court of First Instance of Cebu before the Supreme Court. On December 7, 1906, the Supreme Court decided in favor of the CFI of Cebu and Juan Co.
However on October 4, 1909, in another case that reached the Supreme Court, the court decided that the order of the Collector of Customs was valid and even if Juan Co has now become a Filipino citizen because of the adoption. The Supreme Court, believed in the claim of the American Collector that it is not true that Juan Co was born in the Philippines, but actually in China. Thus the fact that he was adopted by a Chinese who was a resident of Cebu would not give him legal entry to the Philippines.
Juan Co was represented by the known American lawyer in Cebu at that time, Martin M. Levering, while the Supreme Court decision was written by Justice Sherman Moreland.
Aside from Juan Ocaba there were many others who were refused entry by the American Collector of Customs in the shores of Cebu.
- Latest















