^

Cebu News

Carbon Night Market ordinance: Tom warns of legal risks

Caecent No-ot Magsumbol - The Freeman
Carbon Night Market ordinance: Tom warns of legal risks
During a public hearing on the proposed “Ambulant Vendors and Mountain Products Landing and Night Market Ordinance,” authored by Councilor Mikel Rama, Osmeña questioned whether some of the roads designated for vending activities could legally be used for that purpose.
STAR / File

CEBU, Philippines — Cebu City Vice Mayor Tomas Osmeña has warned that a proposed ordinance seeking to formalize and regulate the more than 50-year-old night market at Carbon Public Market could face legal challenges and potentially lead to the suspension of Mayor Nestor Archival.

During a public hearing on the proposed “Ambulant Vendors and Mountain Products Landing and Night Market Ordinance,” authored by Councilor Mikel Rama, Osmeña questioned whether some of the roads designated for vending activities could legally be used for that purpose.

"Ato na’ng klaruhon kay I think some of the roads there are national roads. Cannot be used for vending," Osmeña said.

The proposed ordinance seeks to institutionalize Carbon's longstanding night trading activities, where farmers, traders and ambulant vendors unload and sell fruits, vegetables, flowers and other agricultural products from upland communities.

Under the draft measure, designated vending and landing areas would cover portions of Manalili, Plaridel, Lincoln, Progreso, F. Gonzales, M.C. Briones, Calderon and M.L. Quezon streets, as well as other areas identified under the city's Market Code. Operations would run daily from 5:30 p.m. to 6 a.m. the following day.

The measure prioritizes farmers, farmers' cooperatives, accredited agricultural producers, wholesalers and legitimate existing vendors. It also seeks to regulate vending spaces, sanitation, traffic and public safety while prohibiting permanent structures, unauthorized subleasing and the obstruction of emergency lanes and public thoroughfares.

Rama said the proposal aims to preserve a trading tradition that has become part of Carbon's identity and economic life, supporting farmers, vendors, transport workers and consumers for generations.

The draft ordinance notes that portions of Carbon have served as temporary landing and vending areas for agricultural products from Cebu's upland communities and neighboring localities for more than 50 years. Formal regulation, it said, would protect livelihoods while ensuring public order, sanitation, environmental protection and traffic management.

Osmeña, however, raised legal concerns over the use of roads that may fall under national government jurisdiction, as well as a waterfront reclamation component included in the proposal.

"See? waterfront reclamation zone. Okay. That also is illegal," he said.

Citing the Supreme Court's ruling in the Public Estates Authority-Amari case, Osmeña argued that reclamation activities involving public waters and lands are subject to legal restrictions.

"The Constitution says that the sea is beyond the commerce of man," he said.

Drawing comparisons with Cebu City's reclamation projects, Osmeña argued that the city obtained approval from what was then the Public Estates Authority before reclaimed areas eventually became alienable and disposable.

"How come Cebu City could reclaim? Because it's not part of the joint venture. We got an approval to reclaim from the Public Estate Authority, and it only became A and D (alienable and disposable) after the reclamation. When we applied for it, it was declared A and D, and so we could sell it," he said.

"In this particular case, it is not the government that is reclaiming it. It is a joint venture."

The discussion later took a lighter turn when Osmeña suggested that approving a legally questionable measure could have political consequences, including possible suspension of Archival.

"If you want me to become mayor, huh? Then, get the mayor suspended," he told council members in jest.

"How do you get him suspended? Just approve it…That way, I will become mayor, and you get to preside again (while pointing to Councilor Philip Zafra who was the temporary presiding officer at that time)."

The remark drew laughter from the audience.

Zafra echoed Osmeña's concerns, saying the council must carefully study whether it can legally authorize commercial activities on roads that may be classified as national roads.

"If a public road is beyond the commerce of man, more so, this is a national road," Zafra said.

While acknowledging the livelihood concerns raised by vendors, he said the City Council cannot simply legislate around existing legal restrictions.

"Maybe the law should be changed. We can also lobby to our congressmen," Zafra said, stressing that only Congress can do it and not the City Council.  

TRENDING

  • Latest
Latest
Latest
abtest
Recommended
Are you sure you want to log out?
X
Login

Philstar.com is one of the most vibrant, opinionated, discerning communities of readers on cyberspace. With your meaningful insights, help shape the stories that can shape the country. Sign up now!

Get Updated:

Signup for the News Round now

FORGOT PASSWORD?
SIGN IN
or sign in with