Council urged to revisit measures: Revenue code violates LGC?

CEBU, Philippines — A lawyer representing one of Cebu City's biggest taxpayers has urged the City Council to revisit its proposed 2026 Local Revenue Code, warning that several provisions could exceed the limits imposed by the Local Government Code of 1991.
During the council's final public hearing on the proposed revenue code, Atty. Cresencio Meneses, representing SM Investments Corporation and its affiliated entities in Cebu, raised concerns over the proposed changes to local business taxes, surcharge penalties and community taxes.
Meneses also sought an additional week to complete the group's review and submit a supplemental position paper.
He questioned the proposed shift from the existing fixed-bracket system to an ad valorem or percentage-based tax, saying it could result in increases beyond the 10-percent limit allowed under Section 191 of Republic Act No. 7160, or the Local Government Code, for local business tax rate adjustments every five years.
"For example, for manufacturers with gross receipts of P100 million, the tax indicated in the current revenue code is P176,500," Meneses said. "But under the proposal, that would result in a tax of P375,000. That means there will be a resulting increase in the tax rate of 112.46 percent."
While acknowledging the disparity between Cebu City's business tax rates and those of neighboring cities, Meneses said this should not justify increases that exceed legal limits.
"We recognize that there is a wide difference between the local business taxes imposed by Cebu City as against Lapu-Lapu and Mandaue City," he said. "But we would like to manifest that a wrong cannot correct another wrong."
Meneses also questioned the proposed computation of surcharge penalties, which he said would be based on the entire tax due rather than only the unpaid portion.
He cited Section 168 of the Local Government Code, which he said limits surcharges to unpaid taxes.
"Under the proposed code, the surcharge penalty is on the entire tax that is imposable. However, under the Local Government Code, a surcharge penalty is only imposable on the remaining tax not yet paid by the taxpayer," Meneses said.
Another concern involved the community tax, or cedula, which the proposal would require businesses with branches in Cebu City to pay locally even if their principal offices had already paid the tax elsewhere.
Citing Section 160 of the Local Government Code and opinions issued by the Bureau of Local Government Finance, Meneses maintained that "the community tax is only payable in the local government unit where the principal office is located."
Councilors acknowledged the concerns and said these would be considered during deliberations.
Councilor Harry Eran, however, noted that branches declaring income in another local government unit could still be subject to community tax assessments there.
Eran also stressed the need to balance the city's revenue requirements with the protection of businesses from excessive taxation.
"We also have to consider the provisions that all taxes must not be unfair, unjust and confiscatory," Eran said. "We do really understand that tax is the lifeblood of our operation, but we will not also want to drain our business sector just to fund our various services."
The hearing marked the final public consultation conducted by the City Council on the proposed tax measure, which seeks to update the city's tax and regulatory fee structure.
The proposed measure draws authority from Article X, Section 5 of the 1987 Constitution, which empowers local government units to generate their own revenue sources and impose taxes, fees and charges, subject to limitations set by Congress, as well as the Local Government Code.
- Latest

















