Reining in diploma mills: CHED must enforce its own findings

The Second Congressional Commission on Education (EDCOM 2) recently urged the Commission on Higher Education (CHED) to crack down on diploma mills producing underqualified teachers. It is an important call, but also a familiar one. What the public may not realize is that CHED has already done much of the groundwork for this crackdown.
In 2024, CHED initiated a nationwide evaluation of all teacher education institutions to determine the quality assurance reforms needed in this sector. The agency evaluated teacher education institutions using multiple criteria outlined in its quality assurance instruments, which gave greater emphasis to faculty qualifications, leadership and curriculum alignment with professional and national standards, while licensure examination performance served only as a minor reference.
In June 2024, CHED also approved amendments to Section 25 of CMO Nos. 74–80 and 82 (series of 2017), granting the Commission the authority to issue closure notices and other interventions for persistently non-performing or non-compliant teacher education programs.
The results were damning. While there were outstanding teacher education institutions among the more than 1,600 TEIs, almost two hundred schools were identified for closure because they failed to meet even the minimum quality assurance requirements.
Many had LET passing rates below fifty percent, employed ineligible administrators and faculty members, or continued to use outdated curricula that no longer reflected the Professional Standards for Teachers or twenty-first-century classroom realities.
That evaluation was not just a report; it was a roadmap. The first step was to identify strong, credible teacher education institutions that consistently produce competent teachers. This was done in April 2025 through the Excellence in Quality Assurance in Teacher Education (EQUATE) Awards, where 120 high-performing TEIs were recognized by Executive Secretary Lucas Bersamin and CHED officials. The message to parents and students was clear: if you want quality teacher education, study at these colleges and universities.
The second step, which remains to be done, is to ensure that institutions failing to meet standards are provided with clear guidance and developmental support toward compliance. Only when improvement efforts are exhausted should closures or permit withdrawals be considered. EDCOM 2’s renewed call should therefore not ask CHED to study the problem again—the data already exists. What is needed now is a balanced approach that couples political will with a genuine commitment to capacity building and quality improvement.
CHED’s findings were part of a deliberate reform sequence under the Excellence in Teacher Education Act or Republic Act 11713. The law mandates the alignment of all teacher education programs with national standards and entrusts CHED, in partnership with the Philippine Normal University and the Teacher Education Council, to ensure program quality. Yet enforcement has lagged.
Despite the evaluation’s clear outcomes, many of the low-performing institutions continue to operate, recruit students and confer degrees, effectively turning teacher education into a volume-driven industry. The absence of clear regulatory action not only undermines CHED’s credibility but also penalizes high-performing institutions that have invested in quality faculty, research, and practicum partnerships.
Regulation without enforcement is merely rhetoric. When oversight fails, substandard programs are allowed to persist, undermining the entire system of teacher preparation. This gap between policy and practice highlights the need for CHED to move beyond procedural compliance toward a more enabling and developmental quality assurance system—one that supports institutions committed to improvement while decisively addressing those that compromise professional integrity.
The consequences are severe. Institutions with chronically low licensure passing rates contribute directly to the oversupply of underqualified graduates, who then struggle to pass the board examination or perform effectively once deployed.
This creates a cycle of underemployment, frustration, and attrition among teachers, a problem the Department of Education and higher education institutions continue to face. Moreover, diploma mills devalue the teaching profession itself. When degrees can be earned without rigorous training, the symbolic and professional capital of the teaching credential erodes, and the entire ecosystem of education governance bears the reputational cost.
To its credit, EDCOM 2 has brought national attention back to the issue. But rather than calling for another audit, it should press CHED to act on its existing evaluation and publish a full compliance list of teacher education institutions—including those currently pending review or undergoing compliance checks, and specifying the dates of effectivity—similar to how the Professional Regulation Commission releases licensure results.
Transparency can be a powerful deterrent. Parents, students and employers deserve to know which schools consistently meet or fail national standards. The model is not unprecedented. In countries like Singapore and South Korea, accreditation bodies routinely make their evaluations public, and noncompliant institutions are swiftly delisted. The Philippines can do the same, starting with the list already compiled and discussed in the CHED commission en banc in 2024.
CHED also needs to operationalize a teacher education quality assurance framework that ties program recognition to actual outcomes such as faculty qualifications, research outputs, practicum supervision and graduate performance. This would shift accreditation away from paperwork and toward evidence of competence and impact.
Such evidence, however, should not be limited to quantifiable indicators. Reputation, community engagement and inspiring academic leadership—qualities that cannot be captured fully by documents—can be assessed through peer evaluations, tracer studies, stakeholder feedback and recognition from professional bodies.
EDCOM 2’s recommendations align with a broader reform vision to raise the status of teaching and restore confidence in the institutions that prepare teachers. But reforms are only as strong as their implementation.
If nearly two hundred schools were already found to be failing basic standards years ago, what message does it send that they are still open today? The time for consultation and coordination has long passed. What the sector needs now is closure, literally and figuratively. CHED has the mandate, the legal backing, and the evidence. What remains is the resolve to act. Until then, cracking down on diploma mills will remain a convenient headline rather than a completed reform.
Levi E. Elipane ([email protected]) is a professor and deputy dean of the College of Advanced Studies (CAS). Arlyne C. Marasigan ([email protected]) and Allen A. Espinosa ([email protected]) are professors of CAS and fellows of the Educational Policy Research and Development Office (EPRDO). The views expressed here are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official position of the Philippine Normal University.
- Latest























