^

Business

‘Losing Semirara bidders can’t contest award in court’

Brix Lelis - The Philippine Star
‘Losing Semirara bidders can’t contest award in court’
Sharon Garin
STAR / File

MANILA, Philippines — Bidders that fail to secure a contract in the coal auction, which includes the Semirara mine in Antique, cannot challenge the outcome in court, according to the Department of Energy.

DOE Secretary Sharon Garin said that the provision is intended to give “some form of credibility and stability” to the auction process, which, she said, continues to attract interest from prospective bidders.

“That’s how it’s being done already in many of the bidding processes of the government. So this is not a new provision,” she told reporters yesterday, responding to strongly worded remarks from the Semirara mine’s current operator.

The same rule, Garin noted, also applies to public-private partnership (PPP) projects, where losing bidders are barred from filing court cases to contest the outcome of a bidding process.

Under Section 23 of the PPP Code of the Philippines, no court, except the Supreme Court, may issue a temporary restraining order, preliminary mandatory injunction or similar provisional relief or remedy to restrain, prohibit or compel the bidding, rebidding or awarding of any PPP contract, among others.

Garin said the DOE has so far encountered no issues with the coal bid round, but remains open to reassessing and recalibrating the process should any concerns arise.

“But so far, so good because our consultations were well attended. We got feedback, and we adjusted the terms as we saw fit based on the suggestions of our stakeholders,” the energy chief said.

Semirara Mining and Power Corp. (SMPC), whose 50-year contract to operate the Semirara mine is set to expire in July 2027, has taken issue with the DOE’s expanded asset-turnover requirement, which requires the company to surrender additional assets to the government to join the coal auction.

The company said the requirement would force it to turn over not only hundreds of trucks, heavy equipment and proprietary know-how, but also its power plants and pier.

SMPC maintained that the auction requirement violates Presidential Decree 972 or the Coal Development Act of 1976, declared by then-president Ferdinand Marcos Sr.

Under this law, all materials, equipment, plants and other installations erected or placed within the exploration and/or production area become government property only if they are not removed within one year after the termination of the coal operating contract.

Beyond asset-turnover rule, SMPC said its affiliates would also have to waive their legal and constitutional rights, including the right to question any aspect of the bidding process in court.

SMPC was among the companies that attended the DOE’s pre-bid conference last week. Also present were four companies under tycoon Ramon Ang’s San Miguel Corp.

Ang earlier confirmed to The STAR that his group plans to participate in the bidding, although he said he has yet to study the terms of reference.

Aside from the Semirara mine, the coal bid round also covers two predetermined areas in Cagayan and Isabela.

All eyes, however, are on the Semirara mine, the country’s largest coal mine, which accounts for the majority of domestic coal production.

SHARON GARIN

  • Latest
  • Trending
Latest
Latest
abtest
Recommended
Are you sure you want to log out?
X
Login

Philstar.com is one of the most vibrant, opinionated, discerning communities of readers on cyberspace. With your meaningful insights, help shape the stories that can shape the country. Sign up now!

Get Updated:

Signup for the News Round now

FORGOT PASSWORD?
SIGN IN
or sign in with