Supreme Court: Seafarers no longer required to post bond for disputed awards

A ship maintenance worker is seen in this stock image.

MANILA, Philippines — Filipino seafarers who win monetary awards in labor disputes will no longer be required to post a bond to collect disputed amounts while their cases are under appeal.

Earlier this month, the Supreme Court struck down a key provision of the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers.

The high court ruled that the requirement placed an unfair financial burden on seafarers seeking to enforce favorable labor judgments. The demand, the court argued, puts  them at a disadvantage compared with other workers who face no similar restriction.

In a decision penned by Associate Justice Maria Filomena Singh during its November 11 session, the Supreme Court partially granted five consolidated petitions challenging provisions of Republic Act 12021, or the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers, and its implementing rules.

The ruling, announced Monday, November 16, also invalidated provisions restricting lawyers' fees and legal representation of seafarers. It upheld separate regulations governing maritime education and training.

Bond requirement struck down

Under Section 59 of the 2024 law, monetary awards covering wages, statutory benefits and undisputed amounts were immediately enforceable.

But seafarers seeking to collect disputed amounts and damages while an appeal or judicial review was pending had to post a bond guaranteeing repayment if the award was later reversed or modified.

The Supreme Court declared the requirement unconstitutional for violating the due process and equal protection clauses of the Constitution.

The justices acknowledged the government's interest in preventing "ambulance chasing," or the improper solicitation of legal clients, and protecting the maritime industry against monetary awards that could not be recovered if overturned.

They ruled, however, that these objectives did not justify imposing the additional financial burden on seafarers.

The court also struck down a provision allowing the Department of Migrant Workers' AKSYON Fund to pay bond premiums, finding that the arrangement failed to meet the constitutional requirement that public funds be used for a public purpose.

Consequently, Sections 4 and 5, Rule III of Department of Labor and Employment Department Order No. 247, which implemented the bond requirement, were also declared unconstitutional and void.

The court further invalidated Section 1, Rule XXII of the law's implementing rules insofar as it applied the bond requirement to monetary awards arising from complaints filed on or after the law took effect.

It found that the provision exceeded the authority granted by the law and contradicted Section 94, which preserves rights, privileges and benefits previously enjoyed by Filipino seafarers.

Restrictions on lawyers' fees invalidated

The Supreme Court similarly struck down Section 60 of RA 12021 and Section 4 of RA 10706, or the Seafarers Protection Act, saying they regulate the practice of law.

The provisions imposed restrictions on legal representation, including a 10% ceiling on lawyers' fees, mandatory notarized certifications and undertakings, and rules governing the collection of fees from seafarers.

While Congress may legislate against abusive legal practices, regulating lawyers' professional conduct falls under the judiciary's exclusive constitutional authority, the court ruled.

The Federation of Free Workers, one of the petitioners, welcomed the ruling as a victory for seafarers pursuing labor claims.

"Sa wakas, may pasya na! Dalawang isyu ang inilapit namin sa Korte Suprema, at sa pareho ay nanaig ang mga marino. Tagumpay ito ng mga manggagawa, lalo na ng marinong umuwing may pinsala at ng pamilyang naghihintay ng pambili ng gamot," the federation's national president Sonny Matula said.

("Finally, there is a decision! We brought two issues before the Supreme Court, and the seafarers prevailed in both. This is a victory for workers, especially for the seafarer who came home injured and the family waiting for money to buy medicine.")

Maritime education rules upheld

The Supreme Court, however, rejected challenges by the Philippine Association of Maritime Institutions Inc. and other maritime schools against Sections 75, 76 and 78 of the law.

The schools had questioned provisions transferring regulatory authority over maritime education to the Maritime Industry Authority, linking enrollment to available shipboard training slots and prohibiting tuition or matriculation fees for shipboard training conducted by third-party providers.

The justices ruled that these requirements did not violate academic freedom, describing them as reasonable government regulations intended to maintain educational standards, ensure student competency and comply with international maritime requirements.

The court also upheld the procedure by which Congress enacted the Magna Carta, finding compliance with constitutional requirements, including the three-reading rule, presentment requirements and the one-title-one-subject rule.

It likewise sustained the president's certification of urgency and the actions of the bicameral conference committee.

The Supreme Court emphasized that the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers remains valid and enforceable, except for the provisions expressly declared unconstitutional or void.

Show comments