^

Headlines

ICI flags ex-DPWH chief, others over non-existent Bulacan P95-M flood project

Cristina Chi - Philstar.com
ICI flags ex-DPWH chief, others over non-existent Bulacan P95-M flood project
The ICI will have an operating budget of P41,480,000 until yearend, coming from the Office of the President’s contingent fund.
STAR / Miguel De Guzman

MANILA, Philippines — Former Public Works Secretary Manuel Bonoan and other senior officials betrayed public trust by allowing a scheme that released P95 million in government funds for a flood control project in Bulacan that was never built, the Independent Commission for Infrastructure said in a report submitted Thursday, November 6, to the Office of the Ombudsman.

The ICI's fourth interim report accused Bonoan of "inexcusable negligence tantamount to fraud" for failing to prevent the plunder of public funds under his watch as DPWH secretary.

Administrative charges are being recommended against the former DPWH secretary, particularly for grave misconduct, gross dishonesty, and violations for the code of conduct for government officials. 

"Were it not for the President's 2025 SONA, Secretary Bonoan's inexcusable negligence tantamount to fraud would have resulted in further plunder of public funds," the ICI said.

Project paid in full despite non-existence

The DPWH had awarded a contract to Topnotch Catalyst Builders Inc./Beam Team Developer Specialist Inc. in April 2024 for P95,040,828 to build slope protection structures and waterways in Barangay Bambang, Bocaue, Bulacan. By January 2025, the government had paid the contractor P98,998,749.59 — full payment for a project that was certified as 100% complete.

But when state auditors inspected the site in September 2025 using the location specified in approved bid plans, they found no work or structure at the designated location, according to the ICI report.

The COA report concluded the project was never implemented despite full payment.

"The existence of statements of work accomplished bearing stamps marked 'PAID' despite the non-completion of construction at the approved site shows that the payment was based on a non-existent or unimplemented project," the ICI said.

Conspiracy to defraud government

The ICI found that DPWH officials from the Bulacan First District Engineering Office "conspired with Topnotch to facilitate the release of government funds for a purportedly completed project which, in truth, was never implemented."

The scheme required multiple DPWH officials to sign off on falsified documents at different stages.

Statements of work accomplished submitted by contractor Allan Payawal showed the project at 51.15% completion by July 2024, 89.73% by October 2024, and 100% by January 2025. These statements were verified by Project Engineer John Carlo Rivera, reviewed by Officer-in-Charge Jaime Hernandez, recommended by Assistant District Engineer Brice Ericson Hernandez, and approved by District Engineer Henry Alcantara.  

A Certificate of Completion dated January 17, 2025 stated the project had been "satisfactorily completed in accordance with the Plans and Specifications of the Contract."

The ICI said the approval of falsified statements by DPWH officials shows they either failed to verify the work or "knowingly approved a document that falsely certified compliance with the contract." The Supreme Court has ruled that certificates of completion impose a legal obligation on signatories to truthfully disclose facts, since these documents determine whether contracts have been complied with and authorize payment release.

The audit also found missing documents required under COA rules, including the Agency Certificate of Final Acceptance, geotagged photographs taken before, during and after construction, and test results.

The commission said the "deliberate suppression or non-submission of these essential documents further hindered effective project validation, supporting the claim of an 'intent to deceive the government.'"

Criminal, administrative charges recommended

The ICI recommended administrative charges against the following DPWH officials:

  • Manuel Bonoan, former DPWH Secretary
  • Roberto Bernardo, former Undersecretary for Operations
  • Maria Catalina Cabral, former Undersecretary for Planning and Public-Private Partnerships
  • Henry C. Alcantara, District Engineer
  • Brice D. Hernandez, Assistant District Engineer
  • Ernesto C. Galang, Chief, Planning and Design Section
  • John Carlo C. Rivera, Project Engineer
  • John Michael E. Marcos, Engineer II
  • Ericka Justine P. Chico, Engineer II
  • Claudine Magdalene S. Magsakay, Engineer II
  • Jaime R. Hernandez, Officer-in-Charge, Maintenance Section

They are accused of grave misconduct, gross dishonesty, conduct prejudicial to the best interest of the service, and violations of RA 6713 (Code of Conduct and Ethical Standards for Public Officials and Employees).

Aside from Bonoan, the ICI urged administrative charges against his undersecretaries Bernardo and Cabral, saying their roles made them “intimately in the know” of DPWH operations and responsible for ensuring the proper use of funds.

Likewise, the criminal charges recommended by the ICI are for the following:  

  • Henry C. Alcantara, District Engineer, DPWH Bulacan First District Engineering Office
  • Brice Ericson D. Hernandez, Assistant District Engineer
  • Jaime R. Hernandez, Officer-in-Charge, Maintenance Section
  • John Carlo C. Rivera, Project Engineer
  • Allan Payawal, along with the corporate officers and board of directors of Topnotch Catalyst Builders Inc./Beam Team Developer Specialist Inc.

The commission asked the Ombudsman to file charges for violations of Section 3(e) of Republic Act 3019 (Anti-Graft and Corrupt Practices Act), Article 217 of the Revised Penal Code (Malversation of public funds), Articles 171 and 172 of the Revised Penal Code (Falsification by public officers and private individuals), Presidential Decree No. 1759 (violating material provisions of public works contracts), and Section 65 of RA 9184 (Government Procurement Reform Act).

The ICI also said the corporate veil of Topnotch should be pierced because "it appears that Topnotch was used as a vehicle for fraud, resulting in damage and prejudice to the Government," allowing individuals in control of the contractor to be held personally liable.

Next phrase of probe 

While the interim report focused on the project’s implementation stage, the ICI said the ghost project scheme likely extended to earlier phases, including budgeting, procurement, and post-audit.

It recommended that the Ombudsman conduct a deeper probe into how the project was funded and awarded, noting that “the scheme could not have been carried out without the participation or gross inexcusable negligence of certain public officials and private individuals in securing the necessary funding and facilitating the award.” 

The commission vowed to submit additional evidence amid its widening inquiry.

The ICI reiterated that its findings remain preliminary and that it does not make categorical findings of guilt. Determining liability rests with proper authorities, the commission said.

CORRUPTION SCANDAL

ICI

  • Latest
  • Trending
Latest
Latest
abtest
Recommended
Are you sure you want to log out?
X
Login

Philstar.com is one of the most vibrant, opinionated, discerning communities of readers on cyberspace. With your meaningful insights, help shape the stories that can shape the country. Sign up now!

Get Updated:

Signup for the News Round now

FORGOT PASSWORD?
SIGN IN
or sign in with