(After Binaliw landfill “resumed” operation) Mayor urged: Revoke permit
CEBU, Philippines — Councilor Joel Garganera has urged Mayor Nestor Archival to revoke the business permit of Prime Integrated Waste Solutions Inc. (PrimeWaste) after the Binaliw landfill operator quietly resumed operations late last week, allegedly without the knowledge and approval of the Cebu City government.
Garganera, chairman of the Cebu City Council committee on environment, said the controversial landfill operator blindsided the city government by resuming operations despite the absence of a complete investigation into the January 8, 2026 trash slide tragedy that killed 36 workers.
The Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) had issued a cease and desist order against PrimeWaste, halting operations pending investigation into the incident. However, more than three months later, city councilors were stunned to learn that the facility had quietly reopened under a “partial lifting” of the order.
Garganera, who earlier delivered a privilege speech calling for an executive session to demand updates on rehabilitation, safety, and closure plans, said councilors were caught off guard.
“Yesterday (April 28, 2026) was the 110th day from the January incident, and still there are no results from the DENR composite team’s investigation. Yet they have already started operating? That is unacceptable,” Garganera said yesterday.
He likened the situation to a drunk driver who kills a pedestrian, has his license revoked, but is allowed back on the road before the investigation is concluded.
“Is that justice?” he asked.
Garganera pressed Archival to act decisively.
“Mao nang akong hagit sa mayor ron…kay mao raman nay ilang gitagaan og kabug-aton nga naa nay go signal...naa nay permit ang DENR, nya buhi sad kuno ang business permit…we should treat them as a business establishment…like any ordinary businesses and it is not enough nga ang ilang hinagiban lang ang ilang permit…they also have a lot of explaining to do with regards to the incident. So, I’m urging the mayor to revoke...to revoke the business permit, once and for all, una ta mopadayon sa unahan tagai mi’g husay sa mga panghitabo,” said Garganera.
The controversy was compounded by testimony from Cebu City Environment and Natural Resources Office (CCENRO) head Edita Peros, who revealed that her office had been excluded from the composite team tasked with rehabilitation and monitoring.
Most of the time, CCENRO had also been barred from entering the facility, leaving the office with no choice but to use drones for monitoring.
Peros added that CCENRO was not even informed of the partial lifting of the cease and desist order, leaving them “out of the loop” in a process where they should have played a central role.
Garganera backed her account, noting that even DENR representatives admitted they had been denied entry.
Archival knows
Archival, however, said the city was not blindsided in the same way as the council.
He confirmed in a separate interview yesterday that he had received DENR’s partial approval early this week and said PrimeWaste had informed him of its application to correct its permit.
“For me, there’s no problem with that, as long as it is within the bounds of the requirements. Especially since we are not dumping there at present,” Archival said.
The city’s contract with PrimeWaste was terminated after DENR issued the cease and desist order to the Binaliw landfill facility.
He explained that Cebu City’s contract for garbage disposal remained with Aloguinsan, and that PrimeWaste’s operations might only involve testing or simulation in permitted landfill cells separate from the area affected by the landslide.
Archival emphasized that the landfill could not reopen without an Environmental Compliance Certificate (ECC).
“Take note, the landfill cannot be opened if there are irregularities. It must have ECC,” he said.
He added that the city stood to benefit financially if operations in Binaliw resumed, since hauling costs would be lower compared to Aloguinsan.
“If we pay P4,000 per ton in Aloguinsan and only P3,000 in Binaliw, who benefits? We do,” Archival said.
The mayor also distinguished between the ongoing investigation into the January tragedy and the partial reopening.
“This is a separate thing. If there is a death, we stop one operation, but I don’t think it’s a good idea to halt everything. The benefit is ours if costs are reduced,” he said.
He added that once the city’s contract with Aloguinsan is exhausted, bidding will be opened to all landfill operators, including PrimeWaste, Toledo, and Danao, provided they have ECCs and DENR approval.
On calls for a unified stand between the executive and legislative branches, Archival agreed.
“That’s correct. Once our contract with Aloguinsan is exhausted, we will have to open for bidding. Everything is accepted as long as they have ECC and DENR approval,” Archival said. — /FPL (FREEMAN)
- Latest


















