Sandigan junks Jinggoy plea vs suspension

Sen. Jinggoy Estrada appears before the Department of Justice to submit a counter-affidavit regarding allegations that he received kickbacks from a government flood control project, in this file photo taken in March this year.

MANILA, Philippines — The Sandiganbayan Fifth Division has rejected the bid of detained Sen. Jinggoy Estrada to lift the second 90-day preventive suspension imposed on him as he faces a P573-million plunder case related to the flood control scandal.

In a four-page resolution, the anti-graft court denied for lack of merit Estrada’s motion for reconsideration that sought to overturn the decision imposing the preventive suspension.

In his motion, Estrada argued that he has already served his 90-day suspension as imposed by the Second Division, which is handling a separate graft case against the senator involving the flood control scandal.

Estrada argued that a second successive suspension would “already resemble a punishment rather than a preventive measure,” considering that he would be effectively suspended for a total of 180 days, “which would convert a preventive measure into a penal sanction.”

In rejecting his motion, the Fifth Division ruled that the preventive suspension imposed against the senator is different from what the Second Division issued in June this year, saying the cases pending in both divisions are “distinct and independent.”

It added that Estrada was given an opportunity to challenge the validity of the cases against him and it was only upon the final resolution that Estrada was preventively suspended.

“Thus, he cannot now argue that his preventive suspension in these cases is more in the nature of a penalty when any such variance in the timing of imposition was simply due to this court’s hearing and resolution of the various challenges to the validity of the informations and their amendment which accused Estrada himself raised,” the resolution read.

The court further explained that preventive suspension is not a penalty but a “procedural rule and a measure of precaution.”

It also ruled that there is no pattern of suspensions arbitrarily made outside of the normal course of the proceedings and that there is no reason to consider that the senator will spend the rest of his term in inactivity.

“The imposition of the suspension here is a ministerial duty of the court to impose upon an accused in fulfillment of the statuses under which he is presently being charged with,” the Sandiganbayan said.

The Office of the Ombudsman welcomed the ruling, maintaining that the cases pending before the two anti-graft court divisions were separate and independent from each other.

“We maintain that the imposition of preventive suspension is a procedural safeguard intended to preserve the integrity of judicial proceedings and does not constitute a determination of guilt,” Assistant Ombudsman Mico Clavano said.

Show comments