SC: Seafarers’ bond for seeking damages unconstitutional

Aspiring seafarers gather at the ‘Seafarer’s Tambayan’ along T.M. Kalaw Avenue in Manila in March this year, hoping to secure placements on cargo ships.
Edd Gumban

MANILA, Philippines — The Supreme Court (SC) has rendered unconstitutional a bond requirement for seafarers seeking to execute monetary awards and damages under Republic Act 12021 or the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers.

Under Section 59 of the said law, seafarers seeking to execute monetary awards and damages should post a bond “to ensure restitution should the award be subsequently reversed or modified.”

However, the SC said the bond requirement “violated the Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses of the Constitution (as it) imposed a financial burden on seafarers seeking to enforce favorable labor judgments and subjected them to a disadvantage not similarly imposed on other workers.”

It also voided related orders from the Department of Labor and Employment that enforced the bond requirement, and from the Department of Migrant Workers on the use of its Agarang Kalinga at Saklolo Para sa mga OFW na Nangangailangan fund to pay bond premiums.

At the same time, Section 1, Rule XXII of the implementing rules and regulations of RA 12021 was “declared ultra vires and void” for “contravening” another provision in the law that “preserves the rights, privileges and benefits previously enjoyed by Filipino seafarers before its effectivity.”

Also declared unconstitutional was Section 60 of the same law and Section 4 of RA 10706 or the Seafarers Protection Act, which both imposed rules on how lawyers should represent seafarers in related cases, including “a 10 percent ceiling on fees, requirements for notarized certifications and undertakings and rules governing the collection of fees from seafarers.”

“While Congress may enact measures to protect seafarers against ambulance chasing and abusive practices, the regulation of lawyers’ professional conduct and the practice of law remains within the Supreme Court’s exclusive authority,” it maintained.

On the other hand, the high court upheld the constitutionality of other provisions in the Magna Carta on maritime education and training. It declared that under the said law, the Maritime Industry Authority was authorized to impose “standards intended to ensure the quality of maritime education, the competency of Filipino seafarers and compliance with applicable international maritime standards.”

“Particularly, the requirements relating to enrollment and available shipboard training opportunities were considered reasonable measures to address the availability of practical training for maritime students. The prohibition against charging tuition or matriculation fees for shipboard training conducted by third-party providers was likewise sustained as a measure against unjustified charges,” the SC noted.

The decision penned by SC Associate Justice Maria Filomena Singh resolved the five consolidated petitions raised by seafarers, labor organizations and maritime educational institutions against the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers.

Show comments