MANILA, Philippines — Lawmakers slammed the
quo
warranto petition filed by government lawyers against broadcasting giant ABS-CBN, saying the move is an assault to the separation of powers of the legislature and the judiciary.
Solicitor General Jose Calida asked Monday the Supreme Court to revoke the legislative franchise of ABS-CBN and its communications arm ABS-CBN Convergence Inc. Government lawyers accused the television network of “unlawfully exercising their legislative franchises.”
Related Stories
“We want to put an end to what we discovered to be highly abusive practices of ABS-CBN benefitting a greedy few at the expense of millions of its loyal subscribers. These practices have gone unnoticed or
were disregarded for years,” Calida said in a statement.
According to Rule 66 of the Rules of Civil Procedure, the solicitor general can file a quo warranto (Latin for "by what authority") against “a person who usurps, intrudes into, or unlawfully holds or exercises a public office, position or franchise.”
In 2018, Calida filed a
quo
warranto petition against former Chief Justice Maria Lourdes Sereno that eventually led to her removal from office.
The petition is filed as the House of Representatives continues to sit on the bills that seek to renew the network’s franchise. ABS-CBN’s legislative franchise will expire by the end of March.
‘Pre-empted action of Congress’
Rep. Rufus Rodriguez (Cagayan de Oro), one
of the proponents of ABS-CBN franchise renewal in the lower house, said the move is an “assault to constitutional press freedom and separation of powers of the judiciary and the legislature.”
Deputy House Speaker Johnny Pimentel (Surigao del Sur) called the
quo
warranto petition a “questionable and alarming development.”
“It is only Congress that has the power to grant or cancel franchises.
In this case, the OSG has already pre-empted
the action to be taken by Congress,” Pimentel said in an interview on ABS-CBN News Channel.
He added: “In effect, OSG is usurping the power of Congress. Congress has not even decided whether to renew or cancel the franchise of ABS-CBN and with this development, this can have an adverse effect during the hearing, if ever we hold hearings on the renewal.”
Neri Colmenares, Bayan Muna chair, said the move shows that OSG has become a “biased institution used for President Duterte’s political vendetta.”
Instead of targeting the Lopez-owned broadcasting company, government lawyers should go after public utilities “which have a major impact on the people’s suffering,” he said.
ABS-CBN has been at the receiving end of Duterte's rants, often complaining the broadcasting giant did not air his political advertisements.
House panel urged not to ‘temporize’ action on pending bills
Rep. Lawrence Fortun (Agusan del Norte) said the
quo
warranto petition might be “moot and academic” in few weeks.
“I hope the committee on legislative franchises does not use this as a justification not to proceed with hearing of the network’s application for renewal. This is a sad picture I’m seeing: the committee may not hear the franchise renewal bills saying there’s a pending matter in the Supreme Court related to the validity of ABS-CBN’s current franchise,” Fortun said.
For Rep. Edcel Lagman (Albay), the petition is “unwarranted and misplaced.”
The opposition lawmaker called on the House panel “not [to] temporize its action on the pending bills proposing the extension of ABS-CBN franchise
“because it must maintain its independence from the executive and judicial departments.”
Sen. Grace Poe, who chairs Senate public services committee,
said her panel still intends to tackle the corporation’s franchise renewal despite the
quo
warranto petition.
“The Senate’s jurisdiction over franchises remains despite the existence of the petition,” she said.
Attack on press freedom, loss of livelihood
The National Union of Journalists of the Philippines chair Nonoy Espina told ABS-CBN News Channel that should Congress fail to act on pending bills, this proves that “they are nothing but administration lapdogs.”
“We call on Congress and the Supreme Court to once and for all prove to the people
that they are truly, as the Constitution envisions, independent and co-equal branches of government
that are not at the beck and call of the executive,” NUJP said in a separate statement.
“We must not allow the vindictiveness of one man, no matter how powerful, to run roughshod over the constitutionally guaranteed freedoms of the press and of expression, and the people’s right to know,” the group added.
Up to 11,000 workers, who depend on ABS-CBN and its subsidiaries or sister companies for their bread and butter, fear
to lose their jobs or will indirectly
be dislocated once the company’s franchise
is denied.
“This is not just about ABS-CBN. This is not just about the Philippine media. This is all about whether anyone can or should deprive you, the Filipino people, of your right to know,” NUJP said. — Gaea Katreena Cabico with reports from The STAR and BusinessWorld