MANILA, Philippines — A Quezon City court did not officially count the 58th victim of the gruesome 2009 Maguindanao massacre in its ruling released Thursday.
Judge Jocelyn Solis-Reyes of the QC Regional Trial Court Branch 221 found 43 people, including Datu Andal Ampatuan Jr., guilty beyond
reasonable doubt of 57 counts of murder.
The count for the murder of journalist Ronaldo
Momay, however,
was dismissed as
his body was never found.
The ruling noted that while
it was established that
Momay was part of the convoy of journalists with the
Mangudadatus on the way to Shariff Aguak, he could no longer
be found after 10 a.m. of Nov. 23, 2009.
"Whether
Momay died or was missing after said date could not
be ascertained as no evidence of his actual death
was adduced," the ruling read.
His body
was not found and there was no record of his death certificate.
The prosecution only relied on
dentures, which supposedly belonged to
Momay. The prosecution would later on
fail to establish that it belonged to the 58th victim.
According to Solis-Reyes, the testimony of
Momay's partner
Marivic Bilbao that she would know the dentures belonged to her partner because she cleaned it
everyday for six years since 2003 was an "implausible narrative."
"Who would ever clean
everyday the denture of a loved one or live-in partner when the latter is not physically incapable of cleaning it himself/herself? Is it a normal human behavior?" the court said.
The court added that Bilbao might have made this statement to convince the court that the dentures belonged to her partner.
Patricia
Abellar, the missionary who supposedly made Momay's dentures, initially claimed it belonged to the 58th victim after identifying a stainless wire being closed at its end
that he placed as a mark.
Abellar later on admitted that he placed the same closed ring on other dentures that he made for other patients as his signature.
The court also pointed out the fact that
the dentures were found at the crime scene eight days after the massacre does not prove that
Momay died at the hands of the accused.
"
Simply put, there is no sufficiently relevant proof connecting the object evidence
– the denture
– with the person of
Momay. The mere say-so of the prosecution witnesses that the victim wore the subject
denture will not amply establish its identity," the ruling read.
Momay's daughter Reynafe lamented the court decision as it did not include her father.
"I need justice for my dad. Justice is incomplete when the number is not complete," Reynafe told reporters. — with a report from Gaea Katreena Cabico